Op-ed by Dan Parks, Modded.
Two companies in the same sector can report different Scope 3 totals despite having similar operations and footprints. This is both a capital allocation and investment risk.
Scope 3 figures factor into investment screening, risk assessment and sector-wide target-setting. The stakes rise when the underlying numbers are not like-for-like because of inconsistent definitions.
Why Scope 3 definitions diverge across companies
Scope 3 is the broadest of the three Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Protocol emissions categories. It covers indirect emissions across a company’s full value chain, from upstream suppliers to downstream customers and product use.
The GHG Protocol’s 15 Scope 3 categories, including purchased goods and services and use of sold products, do not carry equal weight for every business. There is no independent, binding rule forcing a company to prove its materiality judgment was reasonable. The output is a subjective discretion point, as businesses decide what to measure and report.
A company in one sector may count employee commuting, business travel and purchased goods, while a close competitor omits several of those categories. They produce two incomparable Scope 3 totals, despite appearing side by side in reports.
A regulatory patchwork leaves companies to decide
There is no mandate forcing Scope 3 category consistency at the federal level. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) adopted climate disclosure rules in March 2024, but they were stayed a month later pending consolidated litigation in the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals.
On May 29, 2026, the SEC formally proposed rescinding its climate disclosure rules in their entirety. The proposal leaves investors with continued uncertainty about any federal backstop for standardised emissions reporting. However, state and international regulators are not waiting.
In California, SB 253 and SB 261 remain in progress. SB 253 applies to companies with over $1 billion in annual revenue. Scope 1 and 2 disclosure started in 2026, while Scope 3 disclosure begins in 2027, regardless of federal action. Other states have similar proposed or pending legislation, such as New York and Colorado.
Regulatory uncertainty means companies in the same portfolio may be subject to different disclosure obligations depending on their location. The regulatory patchwork also raises compliance complexity and makes cross-company evaluation more difficult.
The audit gap undermines investor confidence
With no regulator forcing consistent Scope 3 definitions, independent verifications lend credence to reported numbers.
Researchers found that third-party assurance of environmental, social and governance (ESG) reports has become more common but is still far from standard practice. That share climbed from 16% of companies in the study sample being third-party verified in 2010 to 46% by 2020.
The payoff was measurable for those that pursued this kind of assurance. The quality of Scope 1 and Scope 2 disclosures improved by 26% and 34%, respectively. More rigorous assurance produced even stronger gains. Despite this, many companies limit their disclosure, which means assurance is not always comprehensive.
What investors should demand from companies
Neither regulation nor universal verification guarantees reliable Scope 3 numbers. Investors must ask questions and avoid taking a reported figure at face value.
They can request a clear breakdown of which Scope 3 categories a company includes or excludes, with the reasoning behind those choices. They should also prioritise businesses that pursue third-party verification.
Pennsylvania’s benefit corporation law offers a useful precedent. The statute requires officers and directors to consider non-financial interests alongside profit, and it requires public assessment against independent third-party standards. This naturally extends to Scope 3 reporting.
If legal frameworks already hold companies accountable to external, verified standards and public disclosures, investors have a reasonable basis to expect comparable reporting rigour. This reframes the central ask for stakeholders. Instead of a lower number, they can ask for a defensible, verifiable methodology behind whatever outcome a company reports.
Standards bodies are starting to catch up
GHG Protocol, the framework most companies rely on to define Scope 3 in the first place, is actively revising its Scope 3 Standard. The updated version will consider years of public feedback and real-world use.
The efforts are not happening alone. In September 2025, GHG Protocol announced a partnership with the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) to co-develop a harmonized global standard for reporting. It aims to align Scope 1, 2 and 3 workstreams with ISO’s existing 14064-1 standard.
This effort is both voluntary and international, independent of any single government’s posture toward climate disclosure.
Investor pressure may close the Scope 3 gap
Definitional discretion, regulatory fragmentation and uneven assurance make today’s Scope 3 figures difficult to compare company to company. Momentum exists on multiple fronts. There is a legal precedent for accountability, and standard-setters are actively revising guidance. Investor pressure aligns with where the landscape is heading.
Businesses that proactively disclose methodology and pursue verification may be better positioned as scrutiny around Scope 3 data increases.
About the author: Dan Parks is a senior writer at Modded with over six years of experience specialising in sustainability content. He’s passionate about helping readers convert sustainability promises into practical strategies.

